Restoration logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Restoration logo
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products & Technologies
    • Submit Your Product
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • EDUCATION
    • KnowHow.
    • Podcasts
    • Trade Shows & Expos
    • Training & Certification
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • TOPICS
    • Water Damage
    • Fire & Smoke Damage
    • Mold
    • Contamination
    • Odor
    • Contents
    • Architecture
    • Catastrophe
    • Cleaning
  • BUSINESS
    • Managing Your Business
    • Insurance/Legal Matters
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • VIDEOS
    • Ask Annissa
    • Ask the Expert
    • Ironclad Marketing Minute
    • TradeTalks
    • Video Channel
  • INFOCENTER
    • Mold and Mycotoxins
  • THE EXPERIENCE
    • Conference & Exhibition
    • Convention & Trade Show
    • R&R Special Issue
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP
Insurance/Legal Matters in Restoration

The “Contract Wars” – Part III

Cover Your Backside

By Edward H. Cross Esq., "The Restoration Lawyer"
contract_wars_sl1
contract_wars_sl2
contract_wars_sl3
contract_wars_sl4
contract_wars_sl1
contract_wars_sl2
contract_wars_sl3
contract_wars_sl4
January 9, 2014

In the first part of this series (October 2013), I explained what a contract is, how to draft and interpret contracts, how bad contracts can lead to collections nightmares, and the importance of revisiting contracts on an annual basis to confirm that they comply with new law. In the second part of this series (December 2013), I explained “home improvement” laws, some of the special rules that apply to contracts for residential work, and the most valuable legal parts (MVLP’s) of a restoration contract. In this part, I show how a contract can be a vital risk management tool.

Covering your backside is as much art as it is science. Knowing the law is not enough. It requires an understanding of how restoration projects play out and the obstacles commonly faced by restorers. Drafting an enforceable restoration contract that provides good protection to the restorer requires a series of delicate judgment calls.

LIMITATIONS ON LIABILITY

The well-drafted restoration contract is not excessively verbose, but does include fair but broad limits on the restorer’s liability.

The contract should disclaim liability for acts or omissions of third parties such as environmental consultants and design professionals (architects and engineers). It should exclude liability for undisclosed hazards known by the owner, for pre-existing damage unrelated to the loss the restorer was hired to address, for code violations and for damage caused by the customer or the customer’s vendors. Some states also allow caps on the total amount of liability if it has some rational relationship to the size of the job.

Limits of liability should only be drafted by an experienced attorney because they are subject to intense scrutiny by the courts, especially for residential jobs. They will generally be unenforceable if they are found to be “adhesion contracts,” if they are unclear or vague, inconspicuous or illegible, or the result of fraud. Contracts are unenforceable to the extent they seek to absolve the drafter of the contract from his own malicious or criminal acts, acts known to be unlawful, or his own recklessness.

Contracts which purport to provide indemnity against liability for damages for death or bodily injury to persons, injury to property, or any other loss, damage or expense arising from the sole negligence or willful misconduct of the contractor, or his independent contractors who are directly responsible to him, are against public policy and are void and unenforceable.

Similarly, a limit of liability will not be enforced if it thwarts the primary purpose of the contract. For example, a mold remediation contract that states the remediator is not responsible for mold would be unenforceable for several legal reasons. For one, it is an “illusory contract.” That is, the customer’s benefit of the bargain is an illusion. To be enforceable, all contracts must have “consideration,” which is a bargained-for exchange. The experienced legal practitioner will draft contracts in a way to assure that the limits of liability are not so broad as to make the contractor’s promise so insubstantial that it would not impose any obligation on the contractor.

An “adhesion contract” is formed where a person with superior bargaining power pressures the other party into a contract with unfair or oppressive terms. Restoration contractors are sometimes accused of making adhesion contracts. Adhesion contracts are generally standardized forms offered to consumers on a “take it or leave it” basis. If the consumer has no meaningful opportunity to negotiate the contract, he is stuck (adhered) to it. 

Expect courts to be sympathetic to consumers who sign restoration contracts with overly-aggressive limits of liability, especially on residential emergency service jobs. Just think of the poor, little old lady standing knee-deep in sewage at 3 a.m. being abused by a charlatan contractor. She will remind the judge of his Nana and he will unleash all unholy fury on you. 

The prudent restorer trains all staff members never to say “the contract is not negotiable.” This is not to say that the restorer must comply with every request, just give an opportunity to negotiate and agree to reasonable modifications (with the approval of management, of course). Consumers often ask for trivial changes to contracts. Restorers should agree to them readily and encourage them to be handwritten on the contract itself. Handwritten modifications are given great weight in court. In fact, many people don’t even read the pre-printed text, they just skip to what was handwritten. Handwritten modifications on a contract show not only that it was negotiable, but it was negotiated. It also shows the consumer read the contract, depriving them of the age-old excuse “I didn’t read it.” Take that, Nana!

INDEMNITY PROVISIONS

Indemnity means compensation in money or property for a loss suffered. It also means a contract to save another from the legal consequences of the conduct of one of the parties or of a third person. It is an agreement where one party agrees to secure another against an anticipated loss or damage. Liability insurance policies are examples of indemnity agreements. The insurer is the indemnitor, and the insured is the indemnitee.

Restoration contracts can include indemnity clauses, where, for example, the customer agrees to indemnify the contractor for harm that results from the customer’s failure to keep unauthorized persons out of the work area, or for the errors or omissions of third parties, such as environmental consultants. 

Judicial approaches to indemnity have shifted over the years, but one rule holds firm: If there is an indemnity agreement, the actual words of that agreement will control. The beloved California Appellate Justice William Bedsworth wrote: “If the first rule of medicine is ‘Do no harm,” the first rule of contracting should be ‘Read the documents.’”

ARBITRATION PROVISIONS

A restorer may elect to include an arbitration clause in a restoration contract. Arbitration is process where two or more parties submit their dispute to a third party (arbitrator) out of court. Most arbitrators are retired judges, but that is not a requirement. 

Arbitration is like a trial in the sense that witnesses testify, the parties can make objections, and the arbitrator makes rulings and issues an award. But there is no jury. If the parties have agreed in writing to binding arbitration, they waive the right to appeal.

Arbitration is not to be confused with mediation, which is an informal settlement conference. No rulings are made in mediation. Some courts order parties to mediation, but typically, it is a voluntary process. If both sides appear in good faith, it can be an extremely effective process of dispute resolution.

Arbitration was the rage in the 80’s and early 90’s when courts were backed up four and five years or more on cases. One advantage of arbitration is that it can lead to a quicker resolution because it is administered by a private, for-profit service. The rules of evidence are relaxed, so there are fewer formalities, fewer filings, and less paperwork. This is all designed to streamline and economize the process. Unfortunately, it can be hugely expensive. For this reason, arbitration has fallen out of favor in some circles. 

Being an arbitrator is a sweet gig. Arbitrators get paid for their time––some up to $1,000 per hour or more, thank you very much. Some arbitrators have been accused of being in “no hurry” to finish a case. I have seen arbitrators fail to expedite the process and allow the lawyers and witnesses to drone on and on. This becomes extremely costly, not just in terms of the arbitrator’s fees, but in terms of additional attorney’s fees and additional downtime and disruption for the parties. Every time the arbitrator takes a call, reads a letter or decides an issue, it is billable time. Most good arbitrators are part of arbitration services that charge hefty administrative fees to cover the huge overhead from renting entire upper floors of Class A space in metropolitan centers. Have I talked you out of it yet?

If not, consider this. Filing a lawsuit in court requires a filing fee of a few hundred dollars. Jury fees are about $150 per day, and motions usually cost about $40. Other than that, the services of a court are practically “free” to the litigants (thanks to your tax dollars). Recent nationwide budget cuts have reduced the size of court staffs and increased the caseload of many judges. The efficiency of the late 90’s and early 2000’s seems to have waned. In Riverside County, CA, each civil judge currently carries a caseload upwards of 1,500 cases. To say they are motivated to be efficient would be an understatement. Most of them cut to the chase without all the clowning around that happens in some arbitration proceedings. A judge’s paycheck is not determined by whether you ever “choose” to use his services again. Further, when someone gets served with a lawsuit with a summons issued by a court, they tend to take it more seriously than an arbitration demand.

On the other hand, the recent backlog of court cases is a factor that favors arbitration, which can be considerably faster. Waiving the right to appeal is a double-edged sword. Restorers’ insurance companies want the right to appeal and I have never seen them invoke an arbitration clause in a restoration agreement. Plaintiffs don’t usually want arbitration because it is much more difficult to inflame the passions of a retired judge than a jury. 

However, in some jurisdictions, juries are known for distrusting contractors, so arbitration can be an attractive option. Arbitration is not in a public venue, so there is no public record. If you elect to include an arbitration clause, consider adding a confidentiality clause to keep the whole thing under wraps. An arbitration clause can also include an agreement about the minimum qualifications of the arbitrator (e.g., 10 years construction law experience), so the case is more likely to be decided by someone with expertise in the general subject matter of the case. 

Probably the best part about arbitration is that there is less exposure to a run-away damages award. Talk with your lawyer about the risks, advantages and expenses of having an arbitration clause. The majority of my clients do not have them, and the ones that do almost never invoke them (i.e., the parties ignore them and simply go to court). So the clause becomes useless clutter on the contract.

 So cover your backside, but do it artfully. And don’t try to cover it so much that you end up burning it.

KEYWORDS: restoration restoration contracts restoration regulation

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Ed cross headshot

Ed Cross, “The Restoration Lawyer,” represents restorers nationwide from offices in Palm Desert, California and Honolulu, Hawaii. His firm drafts restoration contracts, collects money for restorers and represents them in litigation. He is the Restoration Contractor Advocate for the Restoration Industry Association. He can be reached at (760) 773-4002 or by email at Ed@EdCross.com. For information about how to document a file to accelerate collections, visit EdCross.com/collections. 

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
To unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • mold remediation

    Fighting Mold and Bacteria Damage

    Successful mold remediation can be multidisciplinary,...
    Mold Remediation
    By: Josh Woolen
  • certifications and licenses for restoration professionals

    Certifications and Licenses Every Restoration Company Needs

    Restoration companies need to make sure they have the...
    Restoration Training/Education
    By: Sharon Elzarat
  • a wall covered in moss and fungus

    Zero Tolerance for Toxic Molds: Essential Steps for Successful Remediation

    Understanding the importance of zero tolerance for toxic...
    Mold Remediation
    By: Michael A. Pinto CSP, SMS, CMP, RTPE, FLS, ERS and Kendra Seymour
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Manage My Account
  • eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Manage My Preferences

More Videos

Popular Stories

Pop Art Female Superhero Punches a Masked Villain

TPAs vs. Independence: The Restoration Industry’s Own Version of the Cola Wars

RIA Carrier Advocate Mark Springer

Turning the Page: A New Era of Trust and Collaboration in Restoration

particle count hands-on demonstration of a HEPA filter

The Truth About HEPA Filters

Submit Your New Product/Technology to R&R!

Would you like to promote a new restoration, remediation or cleaning product/technology with Restoration & Remediation? Fill out the question below to start your submission:

Events

September 3, 2025

The Experience Convention and Trade Show

The Experience Convention & Trade Show logoJoin us in Las Vegas for The Experience Convention & Trade Show, the leading event for cleaning, restoration, and remediation pros, packed with hands-on demos, expert speakers, and high-impact networking. Happening September 3–5, 2025 at Caesars Forum—this is where the industry comes to learn, connect, and grow!

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Doffing PPE

When you are doffing your PPE, do you sanitize between every step?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary.

See More Products
Prepare for CATASTROPHE with R&R!

Related Articles

  • Cross_1

    The “Contract Wars” – Part II

    See More
  • man with magnifying glass

    Cross-Examination: Don’t Mess with Texas Contract Law

    See More
  • ed corona contracts

    How to Set Customer Expectations In a COVID Cleanup Contract

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • CONTENTS_SUCCESS_BOOK-(2)-1.gif

    The Contents Restoration Success eBook! (PDF download)

  • CRIS.gif

    The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

  • secrets-of-insurance-game.jpg

    Secrets of the Insurance Game

See More Products

Related Directories

  • Rytech Restoration of the Midlands

    No one plans for the destruction caused by water, fire or mold, but when it happens, the team at Rytech Restoration of The Midlands is here to help. Our certified specialists provide 24/7 emergency service to get you and your Columbia SC home or business back to normal as quickly as possible. From residential homes to commercial buildings, we specialize in mold remediation, water damage restoration, and fire and smoke damage cleanup. Our live specialists are ready to answer your questions and dispatch a local specialist to your door. Schedule a free inspection and estimate today!
×

Stay ahead of the curve with our eNewsletters.

Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Submit a Press Release
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eNewsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Reprints
    • Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing