Restoration logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Restoration logo
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products & Technologies
    • Submit Your Product
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • EDUCATION
    • KnowHow.
    • Podcasts
    • Trade Shows & Expos
    • Training & Certification
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • TOPICS
    • Water Damage
    • Fire & Smoke Damage
    • Mold
    • Contamination
    • Odor
    • Contents
    • Architecture
    • Catastrophe
    • Cleaning
  • BUSINESS
    • Managing Your Business
    • Insurance/Legal Matters
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • VIDEOS
    • Ask Annissa
    • Ask the Expert
    • Ironclad Marketing Minute
    • TradeTalks
    • Video Channel
  • INFOCENTER
    • Mold and Mycotoxins
  • THE EXPERIENCE
    • Conference & Exhibition
    • Convention & Trade Show
    • R&R Special Issue
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP
Insurance/Legal Matters in RestorationManaging Your Restoration Business

Audit Proof Large Losses: What Triggers Third Party Audits

By Thomas McGuire
audits
May 24, 2018

Nothing in the damage restoration industry is equal. Restoration companies differ, insurance adjusters differ and third party auditors differ; rarely is anyone on the same page. Dissimilar philosophies regarding recovery methods, project documentation and a lack of experience in all areas of the industry have created a time of uncertainty and division like never before in restoration.

Restorer vs. Adjuster

Many on the insurance side of the industry believe all restoration companies are out “milk” the project for everything they can get. On restorer side of the equation, the adjuster is just out to “screw” everybody. Unfortunately, I have seen both of these beliefs in action and generally they are fed by a lack of restoration experience and greed.  

Some adjusters lack restoration knowledge and some contractors operate on an “it is what it is” invoicing system, producing a Time and Materials invoice without providing the proper documentation needed to support the work performed. Following and understanding industry best practices is essential for contractors who want to get paid for their fair and honest services. Experienced adjusters and auditors can quickly spot inconsistencies in billing practices by simply applying industry standard pricing based on decades of facts related to previously filed invoices. Because of all of the information floating around the industry via past invoicing, metrics have been developed and are applied to project invoices in order to make sure the costs are in line. Unfortunately, all auditors and adjusters don’t apply this information in a systematic way, as some, not all, just want the contractor to automatically lower their invoice by 40%.  

Let me be clear, not all auditors are invoice bullies but they are out there. I have seen both contractor misconduct by presenting invoices that are way “out of whack” and also witness to auditors randomly pulling numbers out of the thin air to justify a percentage cut. Generally speaking, when “bully” tactics are not employed by the insurance representative, it is usually the “out of whack” invoice that gets the attention of the adjuster and triggers the audit process in the first place. So, we are back to all things restoration being unequal and it is likely to stay that way for the unforeseen future.  

What has caused this separate and unequal industry and what continues to fuel it today? Mainly, a lack of industry wide experience on all levels of the restoration world from the adjuster, auditor and restorer is the cause and unfortunately this lack of experience is the only spot of equilibrium in the industry. It has become a little bit of the wild, wild, west shoot first and sort out everything out after the dust clears mentality.

Two Types of Large Loss Audits

  1.  Third party auditors perform “Clerk of the Works” services and negotiate pricing, determine the scope of work and monitor the day to day performance by collecting daily documentation of the work performed. “Clerk” services tend to be used on large projects with multiple contractors performing multiple Scopes of Work. “Clerk Audits” are easy for the contractor to manage as long as egos can be set aside and the necessary daily documentation is provided. Clerks represent the insurance company and are there to track the cost of the entire project including all vendors and service providers involved with the project. Communication and transparency is the key to successfully managing a project where a Clerk has been deployed.    
     
  2. “Desk/File reviews” are implemented after the job has been completed and the invoice has been submitted for payment by the contractor. Generally, the trigger for a desk/file review will “trip” because of price issues whereas the overall cost of the project is not in line with the work performed, as compared to similar completed projects.  “Desk reviews” are a costly experience for those who don’t avoid the audit trigger traps while managing large commercial damage projects as most desk reviews result in an average of a 40% reduction of the total invoice amount.

Not every large loss invoice is subject to review and not every invoice submitted by the restoration contractor is “too high”, however, once the triggers have been tripped due to high cost of services, inadequate documentation and poor performance an audit is inevitable.

Audit Trigger #1

The contractor's scope of work or, lack thereof, is the first audit trigger. Any experienced insurance professional can tell immediately if the restorer “has a clue” about what they are doing on the project. Without a clear SOW, there cannot be a clear of understanding of what needs to be done and likewise a clear vision of what the services should cost.  

The contractor can never confuse Time and Materials with “it is what it is” job costing as a budget number should be applied to all T and M contracts. Notice I said budget number and not NTE or Not to Exceed; these are totally different subjects with the budget number simply demonstrating to everyone involved that the contractor has a handle on the project costs. This Information also provides the adjuster with a budget number for the project file. Not to Exceed contracts are a whole other topic to be discussed on another day. 

In order to eliminate the need for an auditor and to avoid the auditing process, the contractor must have the essential Scope of Work and budget number to demonstrate they are in control of the project. An out of control project equals an audit trigger, likewise an in-control project keeps everyone in check. With a solid SOW/work plan, budget number and critical path plan, the contractor should know at all times how the project is progressing. With these plans in place, it is important for the contractor to perform the work according to industry best practices.

Audit Trigger #2

If industry standards for estimating, pricing and performance are not followed, the next audit trigger that will be tripped is in the area of labor cost and allocations. How many workers vs. how many supervisors in combination with labor rate classifications, who is getting paid to do what for how much and does it make sense? If it doesn’t make sense, it will trigger an audit and labor rates will be adjusted to represent the actual work performed and the accurate cost for those performing the work.

Example: If everyone on the project is billed as a supervisor or restoration tech and the work performed is sweeping the floor with no general labor charges, the audit trigger will trip because it doesn’t make sense that CS and RT’s would be needed to sweep a floor.

Audit Trigger #3

The next trigger for adjusters and auditors is equipment usage and pricing, too much equipment for too long with no moisture content readings to justify the beginning and end of the drying process.  “if you didn’t document it, it didn’t happen and getting paid will be difficult.

Critical Loss Audit Triggers

Communicate, Communicate, Communicate.  Bad news doesn’t get better with time…no SURPRISES for the customer. Daily communication/updates with all parties involved is paramount.

  1. Overall cost too high, the trigger is a crazy invoice.  3rd party auditors are called in to review the job file when the cost is too high.  Remember, thousands of restoration projects have been completed just like yours and cost overages are easy to spot with simple math… always ask, how much per sft.? Quick check, if you are over $10.00 per sft. on a standard restoration project, you will probably get audited because of high cost of services.
  2. Labor:  The first place the auditor will start is the supervisor to laborer ratio, labor assignments and labor allocations. Quick check, Standard labor ratio:  10:1 (1 supervisor per 10 workers)
  3. Equipment:  The second place the auditor will look is equipment sizing and allocation. How much equipment was needed for how long at what price?
  4. Production rates:  Did the restorer follow the SOW and Critical Path?
  5. Document, Document, Document.  Once again, if you didn’t document it, it didn’t happen…PERIOD.  How do you get paid for something that didn’t happen? You don’t…NO EXCUSES

 

KEYWORDS: CAT loss large loss restoration

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Thomas mcguire headshot

Thomas McGuire is the founder and owner of Large Loss Mastery – The Solutions Company, LLC.  He is a 35-year veteran of the restoration industry, including commercial property damage, and he is a vital document recovery expert. McGuire is creator of THE EDGE PLUS estimating system, as well as an author, trainer, learner and re-learner.   

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
To unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • mold remediation

    Fighting Mold and Bacteria Damage

    Successful mold remediation can be multidisciplinary,...
    Contamination Restoration & Remediation​
    By: Josh Woolen
  • certifications and licenses for restoration professionals

    Certifications and Licenses Every Restoration Company Needs

    Restoration companies need to make sure they have the...
    Restoration Training/Education
    By: Sharon Elzarat
  • a wall covered in moss and fungus

    Zero Tolerance for Toxic Molds: Essential Steps for Successful Remediation

    Understanding the importance of zero tolerance for toxic...
    Mold Remediation
    By: Michael A. Pinto CSP, SMS, CMP, RTPE, FLS, ERS and Kendra Seymour
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Manage My Account
  • eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Manage My Preferences

More Videos

Popular Stories

Pop Art Female Superhero Punches a Masked Villain

TPAs vs. Independence: The Restoration Industry’s Own Version of the Cola Wars

RIA Carrier Advocate Mark Springer

Turning the Page: A New Era of Trust and Collaboration in Restoration

particle count hands-on demonstration of a HEPA filter

The Truth About HEPA Filters

Submit Your New Product/Technology to R&R!

Would you like to promote a new restoration, remediation or cleaning product/technology with Restoration & Remediation? Fill out the question below to start your submission:

Events

September 3, 2025

The Experience Convention and Trade Show

The Experience Convention & Trade Show logoJoin us in Las Vegas for The Experience Convention & Trade Show, the leading event for cleaning, restoration, and remediation pros, packed with hands-on demos, expert speakers, and high-impact networking. Happening September 3–5, 2025 at Caesars Forum—this is where the industry comes to learn, connect, and grow!

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Doffing PPE

When you are doffing your PPE, do you sanitize between every step?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary.

See More Products
Prepare for CATASTROPHE with R&R!

Related Articles

  • Industry News

    Audit Proof Your Large Commercial Loss

    See More
  • large loss restoration

    Large Loss in the Restoration and Remediation industry… Are You Ready?

    See More
  • effectively using restoration software

    Effective Restoration Software Hinges on the Human Factor

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • secrets-of-insurance-game.jpg

    Secrets of the Insurance Game

  • Cover.jpg

    How To Get More Water Damage Jobs (ebook)

  • COVER pdf.jpg

    How to Get More Restoration Jobs in 14 Days... (ebook)

See More Products
×

Stay ahead of the curve with our eNewsletters.

Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Submit a Press Release
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eNewsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Reprints
    • Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing